Wednesday, 23 June 2010

Memory performance boosted while walking

Psychologists usually think of attention as a limited resource. The more of it you use on one task, they say, the less you have left over for others. Supporting this, countless studies have shown that performance deteriorates under dual-task versus single-task conditions. But what if, rather than having one pool of attention to share around, we have multiple pools for fueling different types of activity. By this account, if two tasks are different enough from each other, there should be no performance decrement under dual-task conditions. That's exactly what Sabine Schaefer has shown in a new study that looks at memory performance whilst walking. In fact Schaefer's research goes further, showing that memory performance is actually superior whilst walking compared with sitting down.

Schaefer's team had 32 nine-year-olds and 32 adults (average age 25) complete the N-back working memory task in three conditions: walking on a treadmill at their own chosen speed; walking on a treadmill at a set speed chosen by the researchers; or sitting down. The N-back task requires that participants listen to a stream of numbers and indicate, in the easiest version, whenever the current number was the same as the number one back. For more difficult versions, it's a repeat of a number further back in the stream that must be spotted.

The headline finding was that the working memory performance of both age groups improved when walking at their chosen speed compared with when sitting or walking at a fixed speed set by the researchers. This was especially the case for more difficult versions of the working memory task, and was more pronounced among the children than the adults. So, this would appear to be clear case of mental performance actually being superior in a dual-task situation.

Why should the secondary task of walking aid, rather impair, mental performance? The researchers aren't sure of the mechanism, but they think the attentional pool tapped by a sensori-motor task like walking is likely separate from the attentional pool tapped by working memory. Moreover, physical activity increases arousal and activation, 'which then can be invested into the cognitive task,' they said.

What about the fact that memory performance wasn't improved when participants walked on the treadmill at a speed set by the researchers? The set walking speed was actually substantially slower than the participants' preferred speed so one possibility is that it wasn't rigorous enough to provide the increased arousal that could be beneficial to memory. Alternatively, perhaps the challenge of walking at a set speed is cognitively demanding, tapping the same attentional pool needed for the memory task.

Schaefer's team speculated that a useful application of their finding could be in relation to childhood ADHD. '...[H]yperactive children might also be able to profit from some type of consistent movement that does not require much attention, even though it is often argued that those children have more problems than healthy controls when they have to divide their attention between two concurrent tasks.'

ResearchBlogging.orgSchaefer, S., Lovden, M., Wieckhorst, B., & Lindenberger, U. (2010). Cognitive performance is improved while walking: Differences in cognitive-sensorimotor couplings between children and young adults. European Journal of Developmental Psychology, 7 (3), 371-389 DOI: 10.1080/17405620802535666

Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.


Rob Keery said...

The article that this post refers to is now available to read, in full, for free, here.

Reflections of a Science Teacher said...

Treadmills with laptops in all classrooms!

Tony said...

This seems just silly to me. We are experts at walking, thus the attentional demands of walking are minuscule. It's hardly dual-tasking. It seems like this benefit could be due almost solely to increased blood-flow to the brain via physical activity.

Justin Grace said...

...or do to the rhythmic properties of activity related to walking at one's own pace interacting with more distal brain systems to lead to greater coherence of the memory trace? I.e. improved synchrony in distributed brain regions leading to strengthening of encoding. Relates to cognitive enhancement using music and tapping tasks in parkinson's patients....

Or due to a greater awareness of the passage of time (in the self-paced walking condition) which allows better temporal encoding strategies? Such that the temporal episodic quality of individual memories is strengthened and so each memory is /more/ unique (i.e. lower signal to noise ratio).

possibilities abound...

Hoover said...

Walking is wei wu wei - the Taoist idea of "action without action" or "effortless action".

I'd guess it's not the action of walking that improves memory, but the effortless doing. Walking would be just one example.

So further experiments might show that any other activity that allows "flow" (see Csikszentmihalyi) would also improve memory.

Anonymous said...

So how does this interact with findings about doodling & memory:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.