Thursday, 5 June 2014

Committed nurses cope with stress by dehumanising themselves and their patients - Italian study

Nursing must be one of the most stressful professions. Not only are the hours long and the work challenging, many nurses are exposed routinely to patient suffering and death. A new study conducted in Italy finds that nurses appear to cope by seeing themselves and their patients as less than fully human.

Elena Trifiletti and her colleagues surveyed 108 nurses (54 men; age range 31 to 50). The nurses answered questions about their experience of stress. They also rated how much patients and nurses exhibit various traits. Some of these were uniquely human (e.g. morality; reasoning), and others were traits usually considered relevant to humans and animals (e.g. instinct, impulsiveness).

Nurses who viewed their patients as less human (in terms of attributing to them fewer uniquely human traits, and more shared human/animal traits) reported experiencing less stress. This was especially true for nurses who were more emotionally attached to their employer, the hospital, and to their patients. This sounds like a contradiction, but Trifiletti and her team explained that it is precisely those nurses who are more devoted to their work and their patients, who likely need to use the strategy of dehumanisation to cope with the stress of their work.

Nurses who viewed nurses in general as less human (by allocating to them fewer uniquely human traits) also reported less stress. The researchers speculated this is because seeing oneself as fully human comes with the expectation that one should share the suffering of others - a recipe for stress when you work with sick patients.

This study is weakened by its cross-sectional design. We can't know for sure the direction of the processes involved. It makes sense to think that committed nurses experience high stress and then cope with this by dehumanising their patients and themselves, but longitudinal research is needed to confirm if this is true.

The findings build on a wider literature suggesting that medical professionals cope with their challenging work by dehumanising their patients. For example, a recent study found that oncologists who attributed more human traits to their patients experienced more burnout. Another study from 2003 found palliative physicians admitting that they used dehumanisation as a coping mechanism.

All this presents something of a conundrum for the medical world. We demand and expect commitment, emotional engagement and dedication from our health professionals, and yet by doing so, we increase the likelihood that they will cope with the stress this creates by viewing us, the patients, as less than human. This is bad news, because, unsurprisingly, there's research showing that the dehumanisation of patients is linked with a range of negative outcomes, including alienation and distrust.

_________________________________ ResearchBlogging.org

Trifiletti, E., Di Bernardo, G., Falvo, R., & Capozza, D. (2014). Patients are not fully human: a nurse's coping response to stress Journal of Applied Social Psychology DOI: 10.1111/jasp.12267

Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.

13 comments:

Janet Choi said...

Nice to see you back at the helm! Looking forward to where you take Research Digest!

Helen Jones said...

Without seeing the study myself it's hard to tell, but from your summary it seems misleading to use the word 'dehumanise' - the traits we share with animals (instinct etc) are not 'less human' just because they are not 'uniquely' human, and the staff are not necessarily *removing* human aspects (which would be closer to the meaning of dehumanise) if they tend to concentrate less on some human aspects in order to cope.

Christian Jarrett said...

hi Helen - devoted nurses who were less stressed tended to rate patients as having fewer uniquely human traits, and as having more traits shared with animals. This was the researchers' measure of dehumanisation, and it's a method that's been used in other studies in this area. Devoted nurses who were less stressed also tended to dehumanise nurses (as a group), but only in the sense of allocating to them fewer uniquely human traits, not in the sense of allocating more traits shared with animals.

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Nora!

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Janet, great to be back!

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Dawn!

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks whoever you are!

Debbie said...

welcome back CJ

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Debs!

Mona said...

Welcome home and hope for more interesting read.

Sarah said...

I know its late but welcome back! The digest would never be the same without you! Thanks to the digest I am carrying on to a MSc in social psychology.

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Sarah, that's kind of you to say so.

Christian Jarrett said...

thanks Mona.

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Google+